Neil Moore


A Review: "Fell Seal: Arbiter's Mark"

I have a deep fondness for tactical role-playing games that comes from my childhood on the Game Boy Advance and Game Boy Advance SP, where I spent many many hours maximizing character levels and equipment and outwitting the AI in a battle as quickly as I could. My favorite game from back then was “Tactics Ogre: Knight of Lodis”, and “Fell Seal: Arbiter’s Mark” strongly reminds me of it in the best of ways. This is a review of sorts and will contain spoilers in some respects though I’ll try to avoid large story spoilers.

To start, the game-play in Fell Seal is a callback to the systems present in those older games with each character having a primary class with specific abilities that the player can moderately customize and progress how they wish. Fell Seal adds a secondary class to each character which dramatically increases the amount of skills and spells available to each character. I enjoyed the increase in variety as it reduced the need for specialized characters within the party and allowed the developers to reduce the size of the parties taking part in battles. Without that secondary class, it would have significantly more difficult to adapt to the different enemy party compositions without grinding up additional situational characters. The amount of classes and types of character are vast, making unique party compositions and combinations of classes in a character ever more numerous. If you wanted a glass cannon spellcaster, you can make at least 12 combinations of primary and secondary classes to make it. More exotic combinations like Templar/Warmage or Gambler/Reaver introduce a great source of variety for both the player and the AI making each battle interesting and fresh as you do not expect a global top-tier spell to come from the guy dressed as a barbarian raider! The class system was a breath of fresh air even though it took some time for the progression and class mastery system to settle in my head.

As far as the actual battles go it was a polished and well-implemented form of the traditional turn-based mechanics I had grown up with Tactics Ogre which felt immediately natural and comfortable. The choice to make items only consumable per-battle rather than globally was an great choice, as I was definitely one of those that would hoard them to the end. Whoever came up with that, I could kiss you! Attacks feel weighty, spells are magical, and animations are short and interesting which is important when you see them so many times in a play-through. Some animations felt too long (such as the animation for the teleportation boots and the teleportation door), but did not take away from the overall experience. One important difference from Tactics Ogre that I was both happy to see and disappointed in was the decision to have projectiles ignore terrain that may be in the way (more on that later). The developers also chose to use an intermixed turn order, though at least you can see who is upcoming and prepare accordingly. The intermixed order does allow skills such as ‘Haste’ and ‘Quicken’ to exist. These two skills are were quite useful in making strategies that can turn a battle around in the blink of an eye by either making a character’s turn come quicker or immediately take a turn, respectively. All of this gives a lot of tools for players to create interesting tactics or one-two combos that take advantage of good interactions between skills.

However, I do have some critiques regarding the gameplay. There are two mechanics in particular that I find not fun at best and infuriating at worst, especially when they interact. The first of these is the aforementioned decision to have projectiles and skills ignore terrain. I can understand why the developers made this choice as it makes being a bow user and certain skills quite difficult to implement and/or use, but I disagree with it. Using the terrain to protect your back or sides is an exercise in futility unless the height differential is quite significant as your opponent can hit you anyways. With how unique and fun the terrain can be in the maps some tactics are simply not possible. As an example, I wish I could send a Reaver or Templar on a flanking maneuver on maps with sheer cliffs like Gyaum Tor and have them keep their back to the cliff to avoid being sniped by Rangers or Gunners on top of the cliff.

The other critique is on how water works in this game. I like how it looks and how characters look while swimming in it. I don’t like how it functions. I don’t like how getting pushed into it as certain classes causes instant death unless you have the hover boots on. I especially do not like how there are skills that cause position swaps, cannot miss, cannot be countered, cannot be blocked, and can be used to throw characters into the water and thus to their deaths. It feels cheap every time it happens to me in a game and I end up reloading a save and trying to rush down that single enemy. A particularly nasty interaction with the mechanic I critiqued above causes even more frustration. During one battle in Kapawka Jungle, a map with a bridge on one side of the map that crosses a stream, I placed Kyrie on the main part of the bridge thinking that she would be safe from enemies down in the water that had the ‘Flip Kick’ position-swap ability. Due to skills ignoring terrain and only using height differences, the enemy used ‘Flip Kick’ to swap positions with Kyrie and instantly killed her. The AI is also unfailing in exploiting this interaction which makes maps with lots of water frustrating and not fun if any of the enemies have a position-swap or push ability.

Some people would say that’s part of the game and I should not have used heavy armor classes on levels with water in them or counteract that with items. Punishing heavy armor characters or players that want a tank-like character rubs me the wrong way and either way you cut it, this is a punishment for choosing to use heavy armor that other classes simply don’t have to deal with. Especially when the heavy armor does not always “feel” like it is worthwhile to use at all.

Equipment in this game has plenty of variety though it can feel like it is not an overly important component in a character’s composition. Increases in character attributes are relatively minor between weapon and armor tiers except for some special items that have large boosts or are just better than normal equipment. It was fairly often I would upgrade equipment for meager 3-5 point increases on two or three attributes. Obtaining special items was more exciting due to real trade-offs between attributes, and the crafting system helped add more of that excitement as the story progressed. A nitpick I have on the equipment was that certain weapon or armor descriptions would hint at special effects the items had but did not actually define or elaborate on them.

An example of this is an intriguing set of cursed armor that hinted that battle sated its thirst. It had poor elemental resistances and was not all that great compared to the armor I had at that point in the game. I had no idea what sating the armor’s thirst meant and I don’t have that much time these days to experiment to find out what it does or if it is just kinda bad armor. It could be that the attribute boosts were worthwhile to lower-level characters or earlier in the game but I was too over-leveled for it at that point. Hard to tell.

The story was a good mix of a “who-dunnit” alongside more classic “we need to save the world, go to these three temples and do stuff” fantasy themes. The relationship between Kyrie and Reiner is much like I would imagine how I would be if I worked with my brother with all the bad jokes and good cooking. The characters you meet along the way each have their distinguishing traits and distinct style to set them apart and show off those traits such as the aloof necromancer, sly bounty hunter, and corrupt noble. The various arcs of these characters’ personalities and mini-stories did not feel out of place or forced. Anadine’s story in particular was one I quite liked, going through here journey as she was forced into accepting a corruptive power and rolled with the punches to grow stronger without becoming resentful of the additional burden nor the quest she continued.

The character creation in this game is phenomenal with a multitude of customization options for everything from eye color and shape to specific pieces of clothing from multiple different classes. You want a werewolf mage? You got it! Want a ninja with a templar armor aesthetic? All yours! My favorite part by far was the abundance of character portraits available. Each of them are brimming with a certain history and type of character behind them. Such as a bright-eyed cleric looking ready to keep everyone up and healthy or a raging ogre warrior ready to tear enemies limb from limb, or anything in between. It truly helps you the player create a personality and backstory for these characters to explain how they look in those portraits and influences how you dress them accordingly.

I had a quartet of custom characters that I grew quite accustomed to:

All of these were an important part of my party alongside the expected story characters, and I came to depend on them. I remember feeling a similar connection to some custom characters in Tactic Ogre, but not to this degree and I credit this to the fantastic character portraits that give a certain personality and distinctness to each character rather than a bland or featureless stand-in (though the game has those too for those who don’t care or can’t decide). This is an additional source of immersion and emergent story-building that I typically find myself creating in role-playing games rather than tactics and strategy games. Definitely something other developers, myself included, should consider when designing character creation or customization options.

All in all, this game was a fantastic ride of 55+ hours and I cannot recommend it enough for fans of tactics games. It’s a worthy addition to the genre alongside Final Fantasy Tactics and Tactics Ogre and I look forward to 6 Eyes Studio’s next adventure!

Thank you for reading this “review” of “Fell Seal: Arbiter’s Mark”! I’m going to be continuing to do reviews of games I play and feel strongly for in this space. There will be other series or standalone posts but I do not have any sort of schedule. If there’s a topic you would like to hear my thoughts on or want to discuss this further you can reach me on the fediverse at @dar13@linuxrocks.online.


Neil Moore's personal website
Copyright © 2020 Neil Moore

This program is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU Affero General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.

This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU Affero General Public License for more details.

You should have received a copy of the GNU Affero General Public License along with this program. If not, see gnu.org/licenses.

Code Repository